Noise control options

Marine and waterside noise control

In briefConstruction on or next to water makes two different kinds of noise, and they need different fixes. Underwater noise from piling and dredging, which marine licences mostly regulate to protect fish and marine mammals, is reduced with bubble curtains and similar systems; an acoustic wall does nothing for it. Airborne noise reaching birds on the foreshore, seals and nearby homes is reduced with tall acoustic walls such as Hushtec's RapidWall, available up to 8 m high, and with shrouds on the noisiest plant.
Underwater view of a bubble curtain rising from a perforated hose on the seabed
A bubble curtain: a wall of air bubbles rising from a perforated hose on the bed, used to reduce underwater noise.

Why is marine construction noise different?

Ports, quays, jetties, bridges over estuaries and sea defences are often built right next to some of the most protected wildlife sites in the country. That changes who you answer to. As well as the council, the work may be controlled by a marine licence from the Marine Management Organisation (MMO), issued under the Marine and Coastal Access Act 2009, and by Natural England where it affects a Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) or a protected bird site.

It also means dealing with two kinds of noise at once.

Underwater noise Airborne noise
Main sources Impact piling into the bed, dredging, vessels Piling hammers, breakers, generators, pumps and plant on quays and decks
Who it affects Fish (such as migrating salmon), harbour porpoise, seals in the water Nesting or feeding birds on mudflats and saltmarsh, seals hauled out, nearby homes
Usual controls Bubble curtains and other noise abatement systems, soft starts, marine mammal observers Tall acoustic walls, shrouds on the noisiest plant, timing and sequencing
Does an acoustic wall help? No Yes, if it is high enough and close enough to the noise

Getting this split right is the most important step. A wall on the quay will not satisfy a licence condition about underwater noise, and a bubble curtain will not protect birds on the mudflats from a generator.

How does a bubble curtain work?

A bubble curtain is a wall of air bubbles, pumped from a perforated hose or ring on the bed, that surrounds the piling and interrupts underwater sound. The change from water to air at each bubble reflects, scatters and absorbs sound energy, so less of it travels out into the surrounding water. Performance varies with water depth, current and the frequency of the noise.

  • Commonly used for: impact piling in rivers, docks and harbours; offshore wind foundations; dredging and other underwater works near sensitive fish and marine mammals
  • Pros: treats underwater noise, which nothing on the surface can; can help discharge marine licence conditions; independent of the pile foundation itself
  • Cons: performance depends heavily on depth, current and design; needs a compressor and often a separate vessel, which make noise of their own; does nothing for airborne noise

How much difference does it make? It depends a great deal on the site. A Cefas evidence review notes that in German offshore wind farms, noise abatement systems reduced piling noise emissions by 15 dB overall. A Belgian offshore trial, by contrast, measured only a single-digit reduction from a single big bubble curtain, with a double-figure reduction only when it was combined with a second system. In its updated advice on disturbance ranges for harbour porpoise, JNCC treats piling with noise abatement of at least 10 dB as a separate case from unmitigated piling.

Closer to home, a bubble curtain around 91 m long was deployed around impact piling during a Tyneside dock redevelopment to protect migrating salmon, described at the time as a UK first for this use. For underwater work, ask for the predicted reduction at your site and how it will be monitored, rather than relying on a headline figure.

How do you screen airborne noise from birds and homes?

Above the waterline, waterside works behave much like any other site, with two complications: the receptors are often wildlife on open mudflats with nothing in the way, and the work is often on a quay, jetty or bridge deck where digging in foundations isn’t an option.

A real example. A contractor building a bridge over mudflats on the Humber, which is protected as a Special Protection Area, Special Area of Conservation, Ramsar site and SSSI, had to stop work because of birds using the mudflats. Hushtec proposed a 6 m RapidWall along the bridge parapet to screen the works from the mudflats. In the end the contractor chose to pause construction until the nesting season was over. That is often the lowest-risk route with the regulator, but it costs time.

Treating the rig itself. On waterside and offshore piling, the hammer is often the loudest airborne source, and a wall on a barge or jetty can’t get high enough to hide it. In Auckland, New Zealand, Hushtec supplied an acoustic shroud for a large piling rig installing piles offshore. The shroud was designed around the rig, on the same principle as the rig-mounted shrouds used on smaller land rigs, but at a much larger scale. Like any shroud, it deals with the noise in the air: piling into the bed still sends noise through the water, which needs its own controls.

The lessons for anyone planning similar work:

  • Height and position matter most. Birds on open mudflats see straight across the site, so the wall has to block the line of sight from the work to the birds. As a first estimate, Hushtec’s working rule is that an acoustic screen should be about 1.5 m higher than the top of the noise source. It is not a substitute for a noise or ecology assessment. See how high an acoustic wall needs to be.
  • Sight matters as well as sound. Birds react to the movement of people and plant, not just noise. A solid wall helps with both.
  • Agree it before the season starts. A wall only lifts a restriction if Natural England or the MMO accepts it as mitigation. Propose it in the licence application or method statement, not once birds are already nesting or feeding.
  • Check the structure. A tall wall on a bridge deck or quay edge needs a site-specific check of wind loading, deck loading and how it is held in place.

What are the limits?

  • Acoustic walls do nothing for underwater noise. For piling and dredging in the water, the underwater controls have to be dealt with separately.
  • Bubble curtains do nothing for airborne noise, and their own compressors and vessels add some noise.
  • Neither lifts a seasonal restriction by itself. The regulator decides what counts as acceptable mitigation.
  • Marine conditions are harsh. Salt, wind, UV and tides wear equipment, so check that anything specified is made for marine use.

What to ask for

  1. Which noise does the licence or consent actually control: underwater, airborne or both?
  2. Which species or receptors is it protecting, and at what times of year?
  3. For underwater work, what reduction is predicted from the bubble curtain or other system, and how will it be monitored?
  4. For airborne noise, does the wall block the line of sight from the noisiest plant to the birds or homes?
  5. Has the mitigation been agreed with Natural England or the MMO before the restricted season?

Hushtec’s marine options

This site is supported by Hushtec, a New Zealand manufacturer of temporary acoustic barriers with a UK manufacturing site in Wakefield, West Yorkshire, where its Performance and Premium panels are made.

Hushtec lists marine bubble curtains among its products, available as supply only or supply and install, for underwater noise from piling and dredging. It does not publish performance figures for them, so ask for a site-specific prediction.

For airborne noise, Hushtec’s RapidWall is a modular freestanding acoustic wall available up to 8 m high, with standard heights of 2 m, 4 m, 6 m and 8 m and other heights on request. It needs no ground anchors, footings or excavation, is wind certified to 31 m/s, has a sound insulation rating of 32 dB, and can be laid out as a U-shape, L-shape, perimeter or corridor. Hushtec also designs pile rig shrouds for marine piling, including a shroud built around a large rig piling offshore in Auckland, and makes custom shrouds and enclosures for noisy plant such as generators and pumps, and says its marine range is rated for salt, wind and UV. To talk through a waterside job, describe your site.

Sources

Common questions

What is a marine acoustic barrier?

The term covers two different things. Underwater, it usually means a bubble curtain or similar system that reduces noise from piling or dredging travelling through the water. Above water, it means a tall acoustic wall or barrier on a quay, bridge or sea defence that screens birds, seals and homes from airborne noise. Most waterside jobs need to think about both.

How much does a bubble curtain reduce underwater noise?

It varies widely with water depth, currents, the design and the noise frequency. A Cefas evidence review reports that noise abatement systems cut piling noise by 15 dB overall in German offshore wind farms, while one Belgian trial measured only a single-digit reduction from a single bubble curtain. Results need to be predicted and monitored for each site.

Will an acoustic wall help with my marine licence noise conditions?

Only for airborne noise. Many marine licence conditions on piling and dredging concern underwater noise and marine mammals, which a wall cannot touch. Where the concern is airborne noise disturbing nesting or feeding birds, a wall can help, but only if the regulator accepts it as mitigation, so propose it before work starts.

Can a temporary acoustic wall go on a bridge?

It can be considered. Hushtec has proposed a 6 m RapidWall along a bridge parapet to screen works from estuary mudflats. Any wall on a bridge deck needs a site-specific check of wind loading, deck loading and fixing, and the regulator must agree it as mitigation before it can be relied on.

Can you put an acoustic shroud on a pile rig working over water?

Yes. A shroud built around the rig's hammer reduces airborne piling noise wherever the rig is working, including on barges and jetties where a tall wall is impractical. Hushtec supplied one for a large rig piling offshore in Auckland. A shroud does not reduce the noise travelling through the water from the pile, which needs underwater controls such as a bubble curtain.

Does a wall stop birds being disturbed?

It can reduce disturbance, because birds react to the sight and movement of people and plant as well as to noise, and a solid wall blocks both. It does not lift a seasonal restriction on its own. Natural England or the Marine Management Organisation has to accept it as mitigation.

Not sure which option fits your site?

Tell us what the noisy activity is, how close the neighbours are and how long the work runs, and we'll point you to what's likely to work.

Describe your site

Live near a site? See how to complain so something happens.

Related guides

Other options

General guidance, not legal or engineering advice. Supported by Hushtec, a New Zealand manufacturer of temporary acoustic barriers with a UK manufacturing site in Wakefield, West Yorkshire, where its Performance and Premium panels are made.